Wednesday, April 28, 2021

We hold (very few) truths to be self-evident

Ever find yourself asking, "Seriously? Why is this even a question?"

There are times -- many times -- when I find myself wondering why some question or issue or situation is being argued about. Sometimes I run across studies that confirm what common sense reveals at much less time and expense, though I guess it's a good thing to have common sense confirmed from time to time.

I am well aware that there are all sorts of "common sense" ideas and beliefs out there that insightful research reveals to be false. Assumptions and beliefs are strengthened by objective evidence.

Is there anyone who hasn't read or been told that "people use only 10 percent of their brain power"? Numerous studies have shown this is just not true and I'm not certain why this myth persists.

But there are other "arguments" that seem to be settled.

For instance, researchers continue to investigate the connections between low socio-economic status of families and relative success on standardized tests, like the ACT or SAT. Anyone who has spent any time in or around a classroom over the past few decades would NOT be surprised to find that there is a strong correlation, overall, between money and testing success.

It's not a direct cause and effect relationship (to build on some earlier posts) since there are plenty of people who overcome all sorts of hardships and succeed in the "education game." There are also plenty of people who come from privileged backgrounds that don't do well at all.

Still, the overall numbers never surprise us. Educational achievement in the U.S. can be guessed quite accurately by comparing ZIP codes of families.

But the most recent  "no brainer" is the discussion about the need for colleges to require COVID vaccinations for all students returning to campus next fall. Many colleges have long required a small number of vaccines for students, and the rationale is simply to provide as much protection from disease as possible in a learning environment that crowds people into tight spaces.

There are exceptions for verified health issues and for religious reasons, but is there really much debate to be had about the need for students to have had their measles-mumps-rubella shots? 

Fort Lewis and Colorado College and DU have announced being fully vaccinated as required for fall of 2021. CSU and CU, among others, are studying the possible requirement. 

And this morning I am asking myself, "Seriously? Why is this even a question?"

NOTE: Metro officials announced this afternoon that everyone WILL be required to be vaccinated in order to return to campus this fall. I assume someone was swayed by my argument (not!).

No comments:

Post a Comment